Drop the Gender Act

Published on 01/09/2021 || Episode 1

Gender identity has never been as present in the media as it is today. Often to condemn it. But what actually is gender identity?

This podcast sets out to spark (or rekindle) questions in you. For maximum accessibility and inclusivity, you’ll find the full script of the episode below — though I of course encourage you to listen to it if you can.

At the bottom of the page you’ll find a list of the resources I consulted while writing this episode, along with a few recommendations on the subject, should you wish to deepen your understanding of it.

Image
Des Constructions - Drop the Gender Act

Translated transcript

Hello,

Let me introduce myself: Simon, 41, white, male and straight. Well… male… I think the most accurate way to put it would be “assigned male at birth”.

Why do I feel it’s necessary to make that distinction?

Because if you asked me what makes me a man, I honestly couldn’t tell you.

And I wouldn’t really be able to answer if you asked me what it means to be a man, either. Or a woman, for that matter.

Because if we refuse to confuse gender and sex (and of course we do), once you set aside stereotypes and social constructs, what’s left?

Let’s give Wikipedia the credit it deserves and no more, but it’s interesting to note that the article on “gender identity” clearly states that it should not be confused with “sexual identity”. It goes on to say:

In the social sciences, a person’s sex or sexual type refers to biological characteristics (notably genetics, chromosomes and hormones), while gender refers to a social construct. Gender identity may not be aligned with sexual identity. It is also distinct from sexual orientation (heterosexuality, bisexuality, pansexuality, homosexuality, etc.). The term “gender identity” is generally preferred (for example, in European recommendations) to the related term “sexual identity”, to avoid confusion with sexual orientation or to centre masculinity or femininity solely on how the person feels, rather than on their biological characteristics.

Transidentity and gender studies are more and more present in public debate today. Sadly, in the overwhelming majority of cases, they’re stigmatised. They make people uncomfortable, because they step outside established patterns and shake the patriarchal foundations our capitalist society rests on.

Identities are many, and they are determined to be recognised for what they are: legitimate, and essential to the well-being of the people concerned.

All of this may seem complicated to you, and despite your open mind, maybe you still feel a bit out of your depth on the subject? If you’d like to learn a little more about it, head over to the episode notes, where you’ll find plenty of resources.

Right, feeling ready for what comes next? Then I’ll carry on.

I was born with a penis. So, as our society insists on doing, I was gendered male. It’s a gender I was assigned at birth. I could use the abbreviation AMAB, for “assigned male at birth”. I was raised and taught the codes of my gender, granted the multitude of privileges that come with it, and that’s how I grew up.

I was born with a penis. So, as our society insists on doing, I was gendered male. It’s a gender I was assigned at birth. I could use the abbreviation AMAB, for “assigned male at birth”. I was raised and taught the codes of my gender, granted the multitude of privileges that come with it, and that’s how I grew up.

That doesn’t change the fact that I’ve never felt like a “man”.

I used to look at other people with penises, or at least people assigned or identifying as “men”, since that was more or less my only point of reference given the model I’d been built on, and I didn’t see much I had in common with them. Why should my genitals, similar to theirs, force me to become like them?

And yet, I went along with it. For a long time. At least partly. Not enough for them. But already too much for me. A complicated childhood and adolescence. Rejection. Misunderstanding. A lot of loneliness. Sometimes even violence.

Until a point of “too much”. Overflow. A story I’ve often heard told by others. You decide to embrace the image that’s being forced on you. When I changed schools, I tried to become “a man”, as they say. I played every card by the rules. I even won a lot of rounds. But I hated myself. I was at that turning point between adolescence and adulthood, and I realised it just didn’t work for me. So I set off on a long, very long road.

A road where I forgot what I’d been taught. A road where I tried to understand who I was. But the question of gender was still too deeply rooted around me. So I just tried to be “a man unlike the others”.

I’ve never felt like a “man”, but I’ve never felt like a “woman” either. Whatever the gender, stereotypes are imposed on us. Expectations. Projections. The result of social constructs. But even though I understand that some people find meaning in them, I don’t recognise myself in any of them…

It took until the dawn of my forties for the light to slowly settle in my mind. A light I let grow in the shadow of a difficult time I was going through back then. That difficult time, as it turns out, wasn’t really unrelated to my assigned gender. Unconsciously, I had once again reproduced male stereotypes, just as my family had taught me so well. Just as my previous relationship had done, too. And for the last time, my assigned gender was going to cause a major loss in my life. A painful break-up.

Since then, I’ve worked on myself. I’ve analysed. I’ve built something else. To become the person I am now. A person who no longer obeys the commands of the stereotypes of the gender assigned to them at birth.

That doesn’t make me a better person than anyone else. It doesn’t erase my past mistakes. I’ll probably make more of them, too.

I am not a man. I am not a woman. I am not a mix of the two. I don’t understand how to apply the notion of gender to who I am.

Simple as that.

There’s no way to gender me without limiting me. Without constraining me. Without imposing behaviours, intentions and ways of functioning that aren’t mine. I have no gender. I’m just me. A person on the non-binary spectrum, and agender, to be more precise.

So the people who interact with me regularly are going to ask, “What does that change? How should I change the way I address you to respect this?”. And I’ll just tell you that if you’re already close to me, you don’t need to change a thing. I stopped surrounding myself with people who don’t respect me a long time ago. If you’re here, don’t change anything.

I won’t be changing my first name either, because if my genitals don’t determine who I am, there’s no reason a string of letters should change anything. So I’ll stay Simon. Even though for more than 20 years now, a lot of people have called me Maune. The choice is yours.

I don’t mind which pronoun you use, I don’t mind how you gender your words. Anything works for me, as long as you respect me for who I am. As for me, I’ll probably start moving between neutral and masculine forms, out of sheer habit, even though I fully intend to eventually have this decision legally recorded in the civil registry.

However, I’m asking you not to see any courage in the statement I’m making today. Because it didn’t take any. I’m still a white person, read as a man at first glance (what’s called “male passing”), and I’ll keep the multitude of privileges I was granted by default. The fact that I didn’t ask for them doesn’t give me the right to deny them. My life will remain so much easier than that of all the people affected by racism, sexism, homophobia and transphobia, to name just those struggles. If I’m sharing this, it’s purely to be at peace with myself. To help others understand who I am. Maybe to help others understand who they are. Because it took me 41 years to build who I am, and I’m not ashamed of it. I’ll “just” try, as always, to put my privileges to work for something bigger than me, to give a voice to people who have too little of one. While doing my best to shut up when I risk stealing the spotlight from those who get it far too rarely.

Actually, there’s one more thing I need to figure out with myself! I told you at the start of this podcast that I’m straight. I sometimes tended to describe myself as heteroflexible, or a potential bi who maybe just never met a man who could win him over. But since I have no gender, that makes me question this, and the reality and depth of my attractions. The coming months are going to be full of reflection again, and I’ll be sure to make another episode to talk about it with you.

And with that, I’ll say goodbye.

Your devoted podcaster.

Simon

Resources