In a Relationship, Should You Have to Make an Effort?

Published on 14/02/2022 || Episode 6

Ah, February 14th and Valentine’s Day. Let’s revisit the idea that for a couple to enjoy plenty of love, it’s going to take effort!

This podcast sets out to spark (or rekindle) questions in you. For maximum accessibility and inclusivity, you’ll find the full script of the episode below — though I of course encourage you to listen to it if you can.

At the bottom of the page you’ll find a list of the resources I consulted while writing this episode, along with a few recommendations on the subject, should you wish to deepen your understanding of it.

Image
Des Constructions - In a Relationship, Should You Have to Make an Effort?

Translated transcript

Aaaah, February. February 14th. Valentine’s Day. How could I not take the opportunity to talk briefly, not about love this time, but about relationships?

A few months ago now, while I was taking part in a round table where we were talking about relationships and couples, a point of disagreement came up. And strangely enough, I defended a position that wouldn’t have been mine just a few years ago.

The question, as you’ve guessed, is in the title of the episode: in a relationship, should you make an effort?

As always, I’m going to think back over my own path to see how this question has played out in my life, which has been a series of changes and self-questioning. Nobody’s perfect, and like everyone else, I’m far from it. That doesn’t change the fact that I’ve opened my eyes to quite a few things, and above all to what led me to those changes.

I think the first thing to establish is that no, it’s not within our power to change another person. We can be a motivation. We can be an example, an inspiration, but we can’t change someone who has no intention of changing. And that’s the whole problem when we talk about “making an effort”.

But what is an effort?

According to the Larousse dictionary, when it refers to conscious beings, here’s the definition: ”The voluntary mobilisation of physical, intellectual or moral forces in order to resist or to overcome resistance”.

And when it comes to materials: “An internal force caused in a structure by external actions.”

So effort would be a constant action that has to be sustained to overcome resistance. But that resistance is actually ourselves. It means going against what we’re made of in order to take on another “shape”, in a way.

But effort also implies hardship. It implies fatigue. So sooner or later, it inevitably leads to giving up out of exhaustion. Like an athlete who sustains a superhuman effort but, at some point or another, has to stop and return to their “normal” state.

Which brings me back to my story.

There have been times in my life when I made an effort. Intense and sincere efforts. But each time, I wore myself out, because you can’t keep making an effort every moment, forever.

Back then, my efforts were mainly about a kind of mental load that my brain just couldn’t handle. So it tended to offload it, and even though I did so without any ill intent, it inevitably had an impact on the people around me, and especially on my relationship. So, very regularly, I’d “pull myself together”, as they say, and decide to pay attention, to make an effort. I’d promise it as sincerely as can be, and even stick to it for a while. But life is what it is. With overfilled lives and indecent schedules, I’d end up letting my guard down and letting other things take over, until frustration built up on my partner’s side again and led us to another tense situation that led to the same pattern… over and over… Because making an effort can only last so long.

That said, don’t get me wrong! This isn’t about excusing every behaviour and accepting anything and everything. It’s not about accepting a toxic relationship, unwillingness, lame excuses, …

I can only speak from my own experience, obviously, but I know I only managed to start making those changes once I had internalised them. I had to manage to see who I really was and what my behaviours, shortcomings and underlying patterns were, the ones I had preferred not to see until then. Then I compared that picture of myself with the person I wanted to be. Or even with the person I thought I was. That’s bound to be a nasty slap in the face.

It’s something I still do regularly to discover new things about myself, and I’ll keep discovering them, I think, until the day I die.

Since then, I no longer make efforts. But that doesn’t mean I don’t change. The difference is that I do it for myself. Because I’m not the person I want to be. Having taken a step back allows me to analyse my own behaviours that I’ve identified as not being in line with who I am, and I can, most of the time, avoid them.

Nobody will be able to change me, and neither will any effort I make for someone else. But once again, I regret taking far too many years to take that step back and understand what was keeping me from who I wanted to be and thought I was. It cost me a relationship that was dear to me. That’s a price I’d rather not have had to pay to learn.

One question remains open: what if the person I want to be isn’t the person the other wants me to be?

Making an effort won’t change you. It’s just not you that this person loves, but a projection of a fantasised you that you’ll probably never be.

So no, I don’t think making an effort is the solution to problems in a relationship. I do think, however, that good communication could allow each person involved to help the other see more clearly who they are within the relationship, and to grow together to become those people.

Today, I’m a little closer to the person I thought I was, but still a long way from the one I’d like to be. Fortunately, I have the rest of my life to keep getting closer.

And for this episode, I’ll share only one resource in the notes. It’s Daniel Sloss’s show Jigsaw. From about halfway through, he sets out a wonderful analogy that might blow your mind, as it did mine, brilliantly illustrating an idea I’d had for a while already.

Enjoy the show.

Feel free to come and discuss it on social media; my links are in the description.