Non-Monogamy

Published on 01/11/2021 || Episode 3

Behind the old reference hidden in this episode’s cover art, we’re going to talk about a subject particularly close to my heart. Love. We’ll question monogamy and explore the other possibilities open to us, such as non-monogamy and polyamory in particular.

This podcast sets out to spark (or rekindle) questions in you. For maximum accessibility and inclusivity, you’ll find the full script of the episode below — though I of course encourage you to listen to it if you can.

At the bottom of the page you’ll find a list of the resources I consulted while writing this episode, along with a few recommendations on the subject, should you wish to deepen your understanding of it.

Image
Des Constructions - Non-Monogamy

Translated transcript

As I’m only just starting to write this episode, it already seems clear that the list of points to cover is long and thorough. More than ever, let me remind you that you’ll find a wealth of links in the episode notes

Today, I’ve decided to talk to you about love. And if I’ve decided to talk about it, as you’ve probably guessed, it’s because I’ve questioned it a lot over the past few years.

But let’s not break with tradition: let’s start at the beginning.

Love, in the common, romantic sense we know it in, wasn’t really a model I was exposed to during my childhood and teenage years. My parents were always together, but their relationship was toxic, to say the least.

My love life began when I was about fifteen, when I started developing feelings for someone I wouldn’t confess them to until five years later. Far too late… because I lacked self-confidence.

It took the release that came with that confession for me to allow myself to feel the same way about someone else. I had shared a few intimate moments, fleeting and isolated, but I don’t think I had allowed myself to love anyone other than her.

So it wasn’t until I was twenty that I had my first romantic relationship. And it lasted nine years. Nine years of an unhealthy relationship, but that’s not what we’re here to talk about today.

Almost immediately after that break-up, I found myself in a wonderful relationship that lasted… nine years as well. But a completely fulfilling relationship this time, one that saw my son being born.

If you’ve done the maths… first relationship at twenty… lasting nine years… then another nine-year relationship… So at the start of 2019, I became single at 39, after 18 consecutive years of being in a couple. I really wanted to understand who I was and what I wanted for my future, because despite a long relationship history, it was actually not very varied, with only two partners.

From those two relationships, I had at least learned one thing each: from the first, that being in a couple isn’t a victory. From the second, that a break-up isn’t a failure. And that realisation would matter for what came next.

I told you I asked myself a lot of questions after that separation, and it’s true. Some very important ones, even, but at first for the wrong reasons.

I was afraid I’d never again find what I had just lost in terms of a relationship. Afraid I’d never find another person who brought together so many of the qualities that matter to me. So I questioned everything for a few days, turned the problem over every which way, analysed my experience and drew the obvious conclusion: exclusivity didn’t suit me.

Obviously, I’m only going to share my own experience, detailing my needs, limits and issues. That takes nothing away from the reality and validity of other people’s experiences. Whether they’re in exclusive relationships or in forms of non-monogamy other than the one I’m about to describe.

I love meeting new people. I love discovering them and learning everything about them. I love that crush phase, when you expect nothing from the other person and just want to get to know them. And yet… I’d often denied myself that.

I’d often denied myself that, because we live in a binary world that doesn’t believe in friendship between people of opposite sexes or genders. During my first relationship, the toxic one, it often happened to me, this sudden interest in someone new, and I sometimes played with fire a little, because at the time I was deeply unhappy in my own home. During my second relationship, things were very different, and I admit those kinds of moments never came up, because I felt so at peace and so good in our relationship and the life we had together.

With this new life beginning and the different paths I could take, I had to think about my needs and my limits. It seemed obvious to me that monogamy wouldn’t be at the centre of it. But at this point, some of you must be wondering, or even misunderstanding, what I mean by non-monogamy, so I’m going to explain how I live it.

Remember that not everyone lives it the same way. The show notes are packed with links to convince you of that and to learn more about the subject.

Love isn’t a finite thing, and that’s a fact, not an opinion.

We’re not obliged to love only one of our children. Only one of our parents. Only one of the animals in our family. Only one of our friends. And yet, when it comes to romantic love, all of a sudden, we’re no longer allowed to love more than one person.

Well… actually, we are. We’re allowed to love several people, just not at the same time.

We’re allowed to feel the most intense feelings for two, ten, a hundred people in our lives, as long as we have the decency to spread them out over time.

That makes no sense to me.

Love isn’t a finite thing.

Loving several people doesn’t mean loving each of them less. In fact, we never love two people the same way. Every relationship is unique. It brings us similar things, but also very different ones. And that’s just fine.

Non-monogamy can take many very different forms. From open relationships to relationship anarchy, by way of swinging, or the form that applies to me: polyamory.

What matters to me in polyamory, but is often misunderstood by people it doesn’t concern, is that it’s a capacity.

The capacity to have several relationships at the same time, and to accept the same from my partners.

Capacity isn’t obligation! It’s not at all a quest to have as many partners as possible. In fact, right now and for a while now, I’ve had just one relationship and I’m completely happy with it. That doesn’t stop us both from staying open to the unexpected.

I want to allow myself to approach someone I meet in a completely neutral way. Without expecting that there will necessarily be any flirting, but without fixating on the idea that there absolutely mustn’t be any either. Knowing that I’m not betraying my existing relationship or relationships just by talking to someone I might potentially click with. That doesn’t mean I’m going to throw myself at every stranger. Just listen to myself, and not run away from any unexpected connection.

Polyamory very often gets a bad rap.

Polyamorous people are hypersexualised. The image of us jumping on anything that moves, sleeping with more or less anyone, and being likely to “steal” your partners if we’re friends is still very present in the collective unconscious.

That’s partly because there’s a lot of confusion around the term. Many people mix it up with swinging, which is generally more focused on sex. Others with the idea of an open relationship, which is also very different. An open relationship is built around the original couple and, in practice, remains fairly monogamous even if it avoids exclusivity. And of course, some people who have opted for polyamory also swing. But that’s not the case for everyone.

Once again, there’s no value judgement to be made about other people’s relationship preferences. There are just models that suit us and others that don’t. Remember episode two and let’s avoid the “I could never do that”. Because all we’re asking is for you to accept us as we are. Of course, some people who practise polyamory and have found in it what they’d always been looking for will tend to try to convince you. And proselytising is rarely a good idea. Even though I believe we’re not made to be monogamous, our societies are designed to convince us otherwise, and it should always remain a conscious choice rather than a default one.

No point lying and painting an idyllic picture either. While polyamorous people obviously don’t, on average, jump on anything that moves any more than anyone else, the risk of betrayal (which here is more about lying than cheating) doesn’t disappear for all that.

It’s also quite hard to meet people outside specialised platforms, because as soon as polyamory comes up, potential partners who aren’t into it quickly run off. And when, by some luck, you find someone who says they’re polyamorous, in practice you often end up with someone in an open relationship who’s only looking for relationships limited to sex, a poly-accepting person who’ll end the relationship as soon as they get the chance to start an exclusive one, or simply someone who doesn’t have the time to commit to a deeper relationship.

Because love isn’t a finite thing, but time is.

And maintaining healthy relationships where everyone can voice their needs and limits takes time and a lot of communication.

Ah, communication. It’s essential for a healthy monogamous relationship, but absolutely indispensable in polyamory. You need to be able to talk about your needs and your limits. Communicate clearly about each other’s availability and expectations. Setting up a relationship agreement, written or unspoken, is actually neither rare nor something to avoid. It takes real work to keep the whole little world that revolves around us running smoothly. Whether your relationship goes for “don’t ask, don’t tell” or, on the contrary, “kitchen table” (which means being able to have several partners in the same room without any awkwardness).

Let’s not even get started on couples who decide to open up to fix a problem in their relationship. I’ve been on the receiving end of that, and it’s really painful to watch your world collapse when, in a moment of panic, the couple closes back up without taking into account the collateral damage they’ve caused. And sexism is still often at play here, when in a straight couple the cis man wants to open the relationship to be “free”, but absolutely hates seeing his partner have more success than him. Based on the accounts I’ve been able to gather, it’s one of the most common reasons for going back.

But why polyamory?

Polyamory means keeping the possibility of meeting new people we might like, knowing we’re not betraying a partner’s trust. With no certainty that it will necessarily lead anywhere afterwards.

It means allowing ourselves to fully discover other people, with no limits other than those agreed with each partner, but also without expectations. Allowing ourselves to feel, as much as we need to, what’s called NRE (new relationship energy), triggered by a new person coming into our life.

Monogamy and exclusivity are also what bring some relationships to an end when, sometimes, we meet someone new who makes us feel different. We tell ourselves it’s better than what we already have. We want to live this unknown, mysterious story, so we decide to end the one we’re already living.

Now of course, if your relationship no longer satisfies you, that’s a completely different issue, but when a break-up is caused by meeting someone new… What’s more, some of those new encounters will lead nowhere. So you end up with a lost relationship, and even if some original couples get back together, the trust is sometimes gone for good.

But I think polyamory is also what made me realise that the most important relationship I have is the one I have with myself.

Other people aren’t responsible for my happiness. I’m not responsible for theirs. I build my own happiness and then look for people to share it with.

I also want to move away from the sacrosanct idea that a relationship has to be long to be strong. I want to be done with the relationship escalator. I’ll add links about the concept in the notes, but we’re talking here about the idea that a relationship must necessarily and constantly move “upwards”.

You have to start dating, then fall in love, then move in together, get married and have kids, buy a little house with a white picket fence, adopt 2 dogs and finally wait for retirement and then death together. Any missed step, any plateau that lasts a little too long or any move in the other direction is generally seen as a failure, rather than a sign of how smart those people were to communicate and listen to each other in order to respect their mutual needs.

I’m full of doubts about whether or not I want to live with another person again someday. Or in some in-between housing arrangement that allows for a kind of everyone-in-their-own-place.

I never again want to promise my “love forever” to anyone. I want to promise “let’s share something together for as long as this relationship brings us both happiness”.

A lot of people don’t feel cut out for polyamory because they say they’re jealous.

Of course, jealousy exists in polyamory, even if I’m lucky enough to feel very little of it. And it’s nothing to be ashamed of. But it’s often more a sign of our own lack of self-confidence than of a lack of trust in the other person. Once you allow yourself to be truly moved by the happiness of the person you love, it doesn’t matter whether they’re sharing that moment with you or with someone else.

You can even tell yourself, “Despite all the good things happening to them, this person always comes back to me. They’re not here out of necessity, but because they really want to be.” That helps a lot in understanding our relationships better.

In the episode notes, you’ll find a link to an episode of the podcast “Émotions” about compersion, which explains this fascinating concept inside and out.

There are still so many things I’d like to cover…

The people who tell us “It’s not a big deal, you have other relationships” when we’re going through a break-up… Denying the unique nature of each relationship.

That we are all unique. That nobody can really take our place, just as we can never really take someone else’s.

The fact that preventing sexually transmitted diseases and infections is, of course, a subject you ABSOLUTELY have to address, even more so with multiple partners.

That a relationship doesn’t necessarily involve a sexual dimension.

Talking about the concept of the “polycule”, which brings together all the people connected to each other through relationships. It’s a concept whose boundaries I still struggle to define myself.

The pitfalls you come across with open couples, like unicorn hunting or the “one dick policy”.

Tackling the question of parenting in a polyamorous context.

But that would make for a far too long episode… So I’m counting on you to send me your questions and, why not, cover them in a bonus episode?

I’ll just close this episode with a point that’s particularly close to my heart: I often hear poly people describe themselves as queer for that reason alone. Well, no, being poly doesn’t make you queer. You’ll find out why in the notes, or maybe soon in a dedicated episode?

Thank you once again for your attention and for listening. And I’d be very curious to know how you love.

See you next month for a special holiday season episode!

If you’d like to learn more about the subject, and this goes for every episode, you’ll find a link to my notes and resources in the description of each episode. Feel free to come and discuss it on social media too; the links are also in the description.

Resources