Published on 01/12/2021 || Episode 4
The holiday season is here. Everything pushes us to consume. More than ever. But why?
This podcast sets out to spark (or rekindle) questions in you. For maximum accessibility and inclusivity, you’ll find the full script of the episode below — though I of course encourage you to listen to it if you can.
At the bottom of the page you’ll find a list of the resources I consulted while writing this episode, along with a few recommendations on the subject, should you wish to deepen your understanding of it.
Translated transcript
Here we are, December already! The season of holidays, presents and decorations. The winter markets are already open or in the starting blocks. The time has come… to consume. We’re counting on you, there’s a whole economy to keep going.
If there’s one thing that defines the overwhelming majority of us, it’s the need to own things.
To collect.
Sometimes to the point of obsession!
Is it a problem? I can’t say for sure, and I’m nobody to judge anyway. But as far as I’m concerned, I needed a change. Because overconsumption… I know a thing or two about it.
Even as a kid, I loved keeping anything and everything. Beyond toys, obviously, I loved hoarding my finds. Later on, I collected everything. Comics first. Lego too.
It all got really out of hand with video games, once I had my first computer. Pretty quickly, the swapping and illegal copying started, and I ended up with hundreds of games, most of which left me completely indifferent. I just wanted to have them all, even if in the end I only used a handful.
And it’s a habit I carried on with the music and video game magazines I kept religiously.
Same with the weekly trips to the media library’s lending desk to copy hundreds of music CDs, which I ripped to MP3 for years. I’d piled up more music than anyone could listen to in a lifetime, giving my Winamp a bad case of indigestion and making it almost unusable as it struggled to keep up with indexing all those useless files.
Then DivX came along and, like many of you, I owned binders full of CDs of downloaded films, before throwing them all out a few years later when HD arrived.
A severe case of collector’s fever.
And that was only the beginning.
I bought tons of DVDs, CDs, books, comics, … my passion for video games made me buy every console that came out, for years, and indecent quantities of games. Consoles and games I stored in boxes cluttering up my basement once the next generation arrived, and that I only ever touched again to move house.
The arrival of digital with Steam didn’t help. Ah, the famous Steam sales… I’ve already talked about them in an episode of l’École des FAQ, which you’ll find in the show notes, by the way. Impulse purchases… compulsive ones, even… and a fair number of games in the pile that I’ll… never play.
But one day… everything changed.
I honestly can’t tell whether it was gradual or sudden.
Maybe with the arrival of Spotify and Netflix. Being able to access content without having to pile it up on my shelves or hard drives inevitably changed the way I looked at ownership. I came to realise that the pleasure of owning had, for a while now, outweighed my pleasure in enjoying what I had at my disposal.
I think the next step was realising that all those boxes I was storing had real value. Dormant value I could have used differently. I’m not at all into speculating and keeping everything in order to resell it later for a fortune to people who might truly appreciate my relics.
In fact, the idea of selling everything at a reasonable price won out, and with that money, I was able to buy my son a Switch and some games.
So I sold everything. And I realised it just made me lighter.
That was the tipping point that got me interested in minimalism, without really putting a name to it, until I watched the documentary of the same name on Netflix (you’ll find the link in the notes). I needed to realise that, back then, I existed through my possessions, and that I was using them almost as a kind of identity to assert who I was.
So, even though unlike Marie Kondo I don’t thank my old possessions when I decide to part with them, just like her, I’m learning to limit myself to what actually serves me.
I make sure I never again exist through my possessions, but own what serves my existence.
I don’t buy many physical cultural products anymore; I’d rather make do with digital versions, which I also find much more convenient to use.
On the other hand… I don’t forbid myself from buying things that help me enjoy the moments I live. Whether it’s musical instruments, podcasting or photography gear, …. For everything that helps me create and explore my creative potential, I don’t hesitate.
Well… I don’t hesitate… This is where my environmental conscience kicks in.
Consuming and collecting, beyond the financial impact and the space it takes up, also means using rare resources, most of which are finite, as I discussed in another episode of l’École des FAQ, which you’ll also find in the show notes.
To ease that guilt, I go for second-hand purchases whenever I can. Just as I once let fans of old consoles enjoy my former collection, today I get to enjoy other people’s barely used gear at a lower price.
That was my version of a Christmas tale. My own needs, limits and desires.
That said, aside from speculators, who are as toxic as the people who stockpile toilet paper during pandemics, I completely understand the opposite needs.
It’s hard to live on little in a society that only survives through economic growth.
Working more, and often too much.
To produce more than will be bought.
To buy more than we can afford.
COVID was quite the warning shot, by the way, showing just how fragile this system is.
And even apart from that, think of all the commercial holidays scattered throughout the year! Valentine’s Day, Easter, Mother’s, Father’s and Grandparents’ Days, Saint Nicholas here in Belgium, Christmas… and I’m forgetting a whole bunch (unlike Santa, I hope).
And to get rid of the surplus, sales were invented. Black Friday, Cyber Monday, … all those moments designed to trigger our fear of missing out on a deal by poking at our FOMO (fear of missing out), if we can’t manage to rein in our impulses.
Growth is killing us. Is collapse a reality? Is degrowth possible, desirable, and the solution?
I’m going to keep digging into the question, and I’d be happy to get your links on the subject.
Here we are, a few minutes closer to Christmas and its presents, so I’m wondering whether you’ve written your list to Santa, and whether you’ve started buying presents for the people you love.
As for me, even though I’ve decided to embrace minimalism for myself, I obviously won’t hold back from treating my son and my loved ones to a few presents.
So… happy holidays to you all.
If you’d like to learn more about the subject, and this goes for every episode, you’ll find a link to my notes and resources in the description of each episode. Feel free to come and discuss it on social media too; the links are also in the description.